top of page

Pastries Menu

Pre-Order your favorite treats for any occasion!



Cookies Cakes

Cookies Cakes




Chocolate Chip Cookies

Half Dz - Large ooey gooey chewy chocolate chips cookies.

$15.00

Cookie Quantity

Dozen Cookies

$15.00


Macarons

Pre-order a dozen of our handcrafted macarons and enjoy a curated selection of delicate, bakery-fresh flavors. Made in small batches and package beautifully, they’re perfect for gifting, celebrations, or treating yourself. Reserve yours today to guarantee availability!

$35.00

Macaron Flavors

Assorted (Baker's Choice)

Campfire (S'mores)

Creme Burlee




Spanish Pastries




Quesito (Cream Cheese Roll)

(1) Family Sized 18" Quesito — A flaky, oversized puff pastry filled with sweetened cream cheese and finished with a glossy honey glaze. Golden, buttery, and perfect for sharing. (4-6 people)

$21.00



Fruit Filled Quesito (Cream Cheese Roll)

(1) Family Sized 18" Quesito — A flaky, oversized puff pastry filled with sweetened cream cheese, your choice of fruit filling, and finished with a glossy honey glaze. Golden, buttery, and perfect for sharing. (4-6 people)

$23.00

Spanish Pastries Quantity

Dozen Quesitos

$15.00
Fruit Filled Quesito (Cream Cheese Roll)


Pastelillos (Guava Turnover) Family Edition

(1) Large 8x8 - 9x13" Guava Pastelillo — A large, golden pastry filled with sweet, vibrant guava paste and baked until perfectly flaky. Finished with a light dusting of powdered sugar for a simple, classic sweetness in every bite.

$23.00

Spanish Pastries Quantity

Dozen Quesitos

$15.00


Flan (Baked Custard)

Rich & creamy Puerto Rican baked custard, covered in a pool of rich caramel.

$15.00

Flan Size

6" (Serves 5-6)

$15.00

8" (Serves 10-12)

$25.00

10" (Serves 25-30)

$50.00


Flan-Choco (Flan+Cake)

Flan Cake - Your choice of cake flavor on the bottom, and Caramel Flan de Queso on top.

$30.00

Flan-Choco Sizes

6" (Serves 5-6)

8" (Serves 10-12)

$60.00

10" (Serves 25-30)

$80.00



Brownies & Bars Slabs

Fudgy Chewy Homemade, can be customized for any occasion!




Brownie Slab

Try our 8x8 fudgy brownie slab. Keep it plain or add a specialty flavor, or special decoration. (Not cut)

$22.50

Brownie Flavors

Keep Her Plain

Cheesecake Swirl Brownie

$3.50

Raspberry Ripple Cheesecake Brownie

$3.50
Brownie Slab


Churro Cheesecake Bars

Crunchy cinnamon of churros combined with creamy dreamiest NY-Style cheesecake. Topped with dulce de leche & a fresh juicy strawberry. (Not cut)

$25.00



Ooey Gooey Bars

Gooey Butter Cake / Ooey Gooey Bars / or Texas Butter Cake, whatever you call these delectable dessert, they are the perfect sweet treat! (Not cut)

$22.50

Ooey Gooey Bars


Zesty Lemon Bars

Lemon Bars Recipe has a thick, creamy lemon curd filling baked over a buttery shortbread crust.

$22.50




Pies




Classic Apple Pie

No cans were opened in the making of this pie. We cook down over two pounds of freshly peeled and cored Granny Smith apples with cinnamon and sugar, and then we bake it. If you like your apples al dente, this is your apple pie!

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Banana Cream Pie

Buttery graham cracker crust, filled with fresh sliced bananas, banana custard, topped with fresh whipped cream.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Blueberry Pie

Flakey pie dough, filled with a tart blueberry pie filling, topped with a lattice crust or a crumb topping.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Cherry Pie

Flakey pie dough, filled with a sweet cherry filling, topped with a lattice crust or a crumb topping.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


French Silk Pie

Experience this delightful twist on a classic. Our luxurious French Silk Pie begins with a crust of crushed Oreos and melted butter which perfectly complements the creamy, silky chocolate filling and fresh whipped cream topping with chocolate shavings.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Lemon Meringue Pie

Classic lemon meringue pie that perfectly balances sweet and tart flavors in three distinct layers. The buttery, flaky pastry crust provides a delicate foundation for the bright, sunshine-yellow lemon filling that's both intensely citrusy and silky smooth. Crowning this vibrant filling is a cloud of billowy meringue, its delicate peaks toasted to a golden brown, creating a light, marshmallowy contrast to the tangy lemon layer below.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Key Lime Pie

Dive into our delectable Key Lime Tart. With a buttery graham cracker crust filled with a luscious Key Lime filling. Topped with whipped cream & lime zest.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Rustic Pumpkin Pie

Our new Rustic Pumpkin Pie exudes the warmth and love of the season in a flaky homemade crust. Each bite of the spiced pumpkin filling delivers the comforting taste of traditional autumn spices—cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


To-Die- For Pecan Pie

Prepare to indulge in pure decadence as you take a bite of our To-Die-For Pecan Pie. The buttery crust and dense, luxurious, ooey gooey brown butter filling. Serve it warm with a scoop of ice cream for an extra special treat!

$12.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Strawberry Pinky Pie

Our beautiful strawberry pie, is truly one of a kind! With a strawberry pink pie crust filled with a sweet strawberry compote filling topped with a pink lattice crust.

$10.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


Fresh Fruit Tart

Sweet, buttery tart dough, filled with a vanilla custard topped fresh strawberries, raspberries, blackberries, peaches, & blueberries.

$13.00

Pie Size

6"

10"

$9.00

1 dozen Mini Pies

$20.00


4- Flavor Sheet Pan Pie

Can’t choose just one? Our 4-Flavor Sheet Pan Pie lets you enjoy the best of all worlds. Baked golden in a single pan and divided into four delicious sections, each features a unique, handcrafted filling — from classic apple and rich pecan to tangy cherry and smooth pumpkin. Perfect for gatherings, holidays, or anyone who loves variety, this pie is a beautiful centerpiece that offers something sweet for every craving.

1/4 Sheet Pie (Serves 10-12)

$40.00


1/2 Sheet Pie (Serves 25-30)

$70.00




Party Platters




Brownie Platter

Mini Brownie Platter — Bite-sized, fudgy brownies in a mix of our signature flavors. Choose a single flavor or mix and match up to 5 for the perfect variety. Rich, indulgent, and perfect for sharing (or not 😉).

Small Platter (25 - Mini Brownies)

$40.00


Medium Platter (50 - Mini Brownies)

$80.00


Large Platter (80 - Mini Brownies)

$120.00

Mini Brownie Flavor for Platter

Chocolate Chip

Oreo Brownies

Nutella Swirl



Cookie Platter

Mini Cookie Platter (2oz) — Bite-sized, soft and chewy cookies in a variety of our signature flavors. Choose one flavor or mix and match up to 5 for the perfect assortment. Sweet, fresh-baked, and perfect for sharing.

Small Platter (25 - 2oz Cookies)

$35.00


Medium Platter (50 - 2oz Cookies)

$70.00


Large Platter (80 - 2oz Cookies)

$110.00

Cookie Flavors for Platter

Chocolate Chip

Snickerdoodle

Triple Chocolate Chip



Spanish Pastry Platter

Mini Spanish Pastry Platter — A delicious assortment of bite-sized Spanish pastries made fresh in-house. Choose a single flavor or mix and match up to 5 for the perfect variety. Sweet, flaky, creamy and perfect for sharing—ideal for any gathering or celebration.

Small Platter (25 - Mini Pastries)

$60.00


Medium Platter (50 - Mini Pastries)

$90.00


Large Platter (80 - Mini Pastries)

$125.00

Mini Spanish Pastries

Quesitos

Pastelillos (Guava Turnovers)

Mini 2" Flan



Italian Pastry Platter

Mini Italian Pastry Platter — A classic assortment of bite-sized Italian treats, made fresh with rich, traditional flavors. Choose a single favorite or mix and match up to 5 for the perfect variety. Elegant, indulgent, and perfect for any occasion.

Small Platter (25 - Mini Pastries)

$60.00


Medium Platter (50 - Mini Pastries)

$90.00


Large Platter (80 - Mini Pastries)

$125.00

Italian Pastries

Mini Eclairs

Mini Cannoli's

Tiramisu Shooters


Subscribe to My Newsletter

© 2035 by Carlito's Bakery. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page