top of page

Pre-Order Cakes

Pre-order one of our classic cakes, custom cakes, or build your own cake combination!



Classic Cakes




Almond Cream Cake

The Best Ever Almond Cream Cake. Moist almond cake, filled and frosted with the creamiest almond buttercream frosting. Garnish with Toasted almond slices.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Berries n Cream

Vanilla cake layers, with a mixed berry filling, topped with a whipped mascarpone whipped cream & topped with fresh berries.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Brown Derby Cake

Rich chocolate cake layers, with fresh bananas, fresh strawberries, topped with our classic whipped cream.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Biscoff Cookie Cake

Vanilla cake with crush lotus Biscoff cookie crumbs, filled and frosted with a cookie butter buttercream. Garnished with a cookie butter drip & lotus Biscoff cookies.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Black Forest Cake

Rich chocolate cake layers, with a tart cherry filling, topped with our classic whipped cream. Covered with chocolate cake crumbs.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Cannoli Cream Cake

Tender vanilla cake layers filled and frosted with ricotta cannoli cream. Topped with mini chocolate chips & mini cannoli's. *Not available to be made Vegan.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Carrot Cake

Classic double layer carrot cake with a blend of shredded carrots, warm spices, pineapples, chopped pecans. Topped with a creamy, velvety cream cheese icing frosting!

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00

Carrot Cake


Chocolate Celebration Cake

Rich chocolate cake layers, filled and frosted with chocolate buttercream frosting. Rainbow sprinkles, chocolate candy, & a chocolate drip.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$30.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$40.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$55.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$65.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$48.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$78.00



Cookie n Cream Cake

Tender vanilla cake layers with crushed Oreos, filled and frosted with Oreo buttercream. Topped with a chocolate drip and Oreo cookies.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$30.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$40.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$55.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$65.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$48.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$78.00

Cookie n Cream Cake


Ferrero Rocher Cake

Rich chocolate cake layers, filled with Nutella spread and topped with Nutella buttercream frosting. Topped with Ferrero Rocher candy & crushed hazelnuts. *Can be made vegan, however no chocolates will be used.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$30.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$40.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$55.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$65.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$48.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$78.00



Funfetti Sugar Cake

Tender vanilla cake layers with a hint of almond flavoring, rainbow sprinkles, filled with a strawberry buttercream, iced with a teal vanilla buttercream & topped with a pink drip & fresh mini sugar cookies.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$30.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$40.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$55.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$65.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$48.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$78.00



German Chocolate Cake

Rich chocolate cake layers, filled with a coconut pecan filling, iced with a chocolate buttercream frosting. Topped with a dark chocolate drip & toasted coconut shredded.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$30.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$40.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$55.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$65.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$48.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$78.00

German Chocolate Cake


Italian Rainbow Cookie Cake

The cake version of the original Italian Rainbow Layer Cookies. Made with sweet almond cake layers colored red, green, & white. Filled with raspberry and cannoli cream, iced with a whipped cream frosting, a dark chocolate drip, & topped with mini cannoli's & mini-Italian rainbow cookies.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$39.50


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$49.50


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$64.50


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$74.50



Peanut Butter Overload Cake

Rich chocolate cake filled and iced with a peanut butter buttercream with a sweet chocolate glaze on top and topped with Reese’s peanut butter cups.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Pistachio Ricotta Cake

Enjoy the nutty goodness of our Pistachio Ricotta Cake! Moist pistachio cake layers filled with a sweetened ricotta cream, topped with crushed pistachios.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Raffaello Coconut Cake

Light and fluffy toasted coconut cake layers, filled with a creamy coconut custard cream, iced with a vanilla buttercream, topped with shredded coconut, and Raffello candies.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Scarlet Red Velvet Cake

Ultra moist, buttery, tender and soft cake with the most perfect red velvet flavor. Topped with traditional cream cheese frosting.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Strawberry Crunch Cake

Our amazing strawberry cake layer inspired by Good Humor strawberry shortcake ice cream bars! Topped with glazed fresh strawberries & golden Oreos.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Strawberry Shortcake Cake

Delicate vanilla cake, soaked in strawberry puree and loaded with pillowy cream cheese whipped mousse, and topped with fresh strawberries.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Tiramisu Cake

Delicate vanilla & ladyfinger cake layers, soaked in rich espresso and amaretto, paired with a smooth mascarpone cream frosting and dusted with cocoa powder.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00

Tiramisu Cake


Vanilla Celebration Cake

Delicate vanilla cake layers, filled with a whipped vanilla bean mousse and iced with a vanilla bean buttercream, topped with rainbow sprinkles, a white chocolate drip & white chocolate candy.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00

Vanilla Celebration Cake



Build your Own Cake (BYOC)

Choose your cake flavor, filling, size, frosting, & design.




6 Inch BYOC (Build Your Own Cake)

A double layer cake, 100% custom to your liking!

$30.00

BYOC (Build your own cake)

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0


8 Inch BYOC (Build Your Own Cake)

A double layer cake, 100% custom to your liking!

$45.00

BYOC (Build your own cake)

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0


1/4 Sheet BYOC (Build Your Own Cake)

A double layer cake, 100% custom to your liking! Quarter sheet cake serves 18-20 guests.

$55.00

BYOC (Build your own cake)

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0


6 Inch Heart BYOC (Build Your Own Cake)

A double layer cake, 100% custom to your liking! 6inch heart cake serves 10-13 guests.

$30.00

BYOC (Build your own cake)

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0



Spanish Cakes




Churro Dulce

Double layer - Cinnamon spice cake, filled with dulce de leche filling, frosted with dulce de leche whipped cream.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Coconut Passion Fruit

Double Layer - Toasted coconut cake with a tangy passion fruit mousse, frosted with a coconut cream cheese icing.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Coquito Tres Leche

Double Layer - Vanilla cake soaked with traditional Puerto Rican coquito coconut rum, frosted with whipped cream and topped with toasted coconut shavings.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$40.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$50.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$65.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$75.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$58.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$88.00



Pina Colada

Double layer - Coconut cake with a homemade pineapple filling, frosted with cream cheese icing, & topped with maraschino cherries, toasted coconut & a mini umbrella.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$62.00


10" Large (Serves 25-30)

$72.00


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$55.00


1/2 Sheet Cake (Serves 50)

$85.00



Tres Leche

Double layer - Vanilla cake soaked with 3-kinds of milk, frosted with whipped cream, dusted with cinnamon & topped fresh strawberries.

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$37.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$47.00



Tres Leche (Single Layer)

One layer - Vanilla cake soaked with 3-kinds of milk, frosted with whipped cream, dusted with cinnamon & topped fresh strawberries. (Most Soak)

6" Small (Serves 5-6)

$15.00


8" Medium (Serves 10-12)

$20.00


9" Medium (Serves 16-18)

$27.50


1/4 Sheet Cake (Serves 15-20)

$24.00

Tres Leche (Single Layer)



Cheesecakes




Apple Caramel Cheesecake

Apple Caramel Cheesecake - A smooth cheesecake layered with spiced apple filling on a graham cracker crust, topped with rich caramel sauce and a touch of cinnamon — a cozy, indulgent treat.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Blueberry Crumb Cheesecake

Blueberry Crumb Cheesecake - features a Golden graham cracker crust, a creamy, tangy cheesecake filling layered with a sweet blueberry compote and finished with a buttery crumb topping.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Biscoff Cheesecake

Biscoff Cheesecake - Creamy cheesecake infused with Biscoff spread, set on a spiced cookie crust, and topped with a rich Biscoff drizzle and cookie crumbles — a caramelized, crunchy delight.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Black Forest Cheesecake

Black Forest Cheesecake - A rich chocolate cheesecake layered with sweet cherry filling and topped with whipped cream, dark chocolate shavings, and juicy cherries.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Creme Burlee Cheesecake

Crème Brûlée Cheesecake - A silky vanilla cheesecake with a caramelized sugar topping, combining the creamy richness of cheesecake with the crisp, golden finish of classic crème brûlée.

$17.00



Death by Chocolate

Death by Chocolate Cheesecake - An ultra-rich chocolate cheesecake layered with dark chocolate ganache, chocolate cookie crust, and topped with white chocolate shavings — a chocoholic’s ultimate dream.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Cookie n Cream Cheesecake

Cookies 'n Cream Cheesecake - A rich and creamy cheesecake loaded with crushed chocolate sandwich cookies, set on a cookie crust and topped with whipped cream and more cookie crumbles — a cookies 'n cream lover’s dream.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Fruit Swirled Cheesecake

Fruit Swirled Cheesecake - Velvety cheesecake swirled with vibrant fruit puree on a classic graham cracker crust — a perfect balance of creamy and fruity in every bite.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Dubai Pistachio Cheesecake

Dubai Pistachio Cheesecake -A luxurious cheesecake infused with rich pistachio cream, set on a buttery pistachio graham cracker crust and topped with a toasted pistachio knafeh filling & chocolate covered strawberries.

$20.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


NY-Style Cheesecake (Plain)

New York-Style Cheesecake - A classic, ultra-creamy cheesecake with a dense, rich texture on a buttery graham cracker crust — simple, timeless

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Peanut Butter Reese Cheesecake

Reese’s Cheesecake - A rich peanut butter cheesecake loaded with chunks of Reese’s, set on a chocolate cookie crust and topped with peanut butter drizzle and chocolate ganache — the ultimate treat for peanut butter lovers.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake

Pumpkin Cheesecake - A smooth, spiced cheesecake made with real pumpkin, set on a buttery graham crust and topped with a dollop of whipped cream — cozy, creamy, and full of fall flavor.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00


Snickers Cheesecake

Snickers Cheesecake - Creamy cheesecake packed with chunks of Snickers, layered on a chocolate cookie crust, and topped with caramel, peanuts, and chocolate drizzle — a rich, nutty, candy bar indulgence.

$17.00

Cheesecake Sizes

6" (Serves 6)

$0

8" (Serves 10-12)

$18.00

10" (Serves 18-20)

$38.00



Dietary Cakes

Vegan/ Gluten Free Cakes




6 Inch BYOC (Build Your Own Cake)

A double layer cake, gluten free & dairy free 100% custom to your liking! 6inch cake serves 5-6 guests.

$40.00

Cake Flavors

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0


8 Inch BYOC (Build Your Own Cake)

A double layer cake, gluten free & dairy free, 100% custom to your liking! 8inch cake serves 10-12 guests.

$50.00

Cake Flavors

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0


1/4 Sheet BYOC (Build Your Own Cake)

A double layer cake, 100% custom to your liking! Quarter sheet cake serves 18-20 guests.

$55.00

BYOC (Build your own cake)

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0


6 Inch Heart (Build Your Own Cake) (VEGAN)

A double layer cake, 100% custom to your liking! 6inch heart cake serves 10-13 guests.

$45.00

Cake Flavors

Almond Cake

$0

Carrot Cake

$0

Chocolate Cake

$0

Subscribe to My Newsletter

© 2035 by Carlito's Bakery. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page